cover
tp

Audio Tracks: A Mindful Approach to Recovery

The print version of this book includes a CD entitled A Mindful Approach to Recovery, on which the author takes you through some exercises in mindfulness. We invite our ebook readers to access these audio tracks by going to www.gillmacmillan.ie/coming-through-depression. There are five tracks in all. We hope you enjoy them.

Preface

line1

I first wrote a version of this book 10 years ago, entitled Depression: A CommonSense Approach. In those 10 years, my understanding of depression has changed and matured. As I revisited the pages I had written, I encountered many places where my writing needed greater depth and clarity.

I am grateful to have had the chance to revisit this project and particularly to include a brand-new section on mindfulness. Mindfulness has been shown to offer a powerful protection to people who are vulnerable to depression. I believe this book offers the reader a much fuller account of the path to recovery.

Our lives are interwoven with emotions of all kinds, every day. There are no negative emotions or positive emotions. All emotions offer pathways to understanding ourselves more and more each day, and this understanding enables us to make sense of the world in which we live.

When the way we feel becomes hard for us to accept, when we are having repetitive thoughts about how negative we are as a person, and when we cannot seem to shift this thinking and we feel worn down and at a loss as to how to live in the world, we describe this experience as depression.

Depression is a word we use very loosely, as though it were exactly the same experience for everyone. In fact, it is very particular to each person who feels that way. No single person will feel exactly the same way as another who feels overwhelmed and unhappy in themselves.

Mindfulness means paying attention to whatever is happening in the present moment, and accepting our experience without judging it or trying to fix or change anything. It invites us to relate to our experience with kindness instead of reacting to it and getting carried away by stories about how we ‘shouldn’t be’ feeling this way. Practising mindfulness helps us to calm down, to become more aware of what is going on within us, and to meet our difficulties with honesty and acceptance.

What if the way you feel right now is the only way you can feel in this particular moment? What if this moment doesn’t get any better than it is right now? What if it were possible to hold our experience in awareness and allow it to be just the way it already is?

That would be an incredibly radical act, says Jon Kabat-Zinn, a pioneer in mindfulness training, but it would also be an act of profound wisdom. We would stop struggling against the way things are. We would start to investigate what is happening and see that inside of our sadness, our grief and our despair, there is something else going on; some kind of deep understanding in us that recognises that loss is real for all of us, that disappointment is inevitable, that everything is changing, that our bodies age, and that we can’t control the universe, much as we would like to.

And this is not all black, because we have evolved over billions of years to deal precisely with this type of reality. There is no other reality. We are fragile and we can be broken – but we also have within us a capacity to adapt, to be changed and to evolve through facing our difficulties.

For many of us, it is hard to stop and take time to step into the present moment. Our mind is always on the way to somewhere else. We blast through our days and weeks, living somewhere in the future a lot of the time. We tell ourselves that we will only be able to settle in the present when the conditions are right, but of course they are never right.

The truth is that we don’t believe that we can find happiness in the present moment. In fact, we are more likely to believe that we will only find happiness if we steer clear of the present.

Maybe we are afraid of what we might find there – unpleasant and painful feelings that we fear could overwhelm us – and we would rather push them out of our minds and steer clear of them. We may even be reluctant to stop and appreciate pleasant experiences, because we always imagine there will be an even better time, somewhere in the future, when everything will be just the way we want it, and when we can be really happy.

So we tend to live lives where we constantly distract ourselves. We worry or fantasise about what might happen, or we brood over the past, regretting what has happened, running it over and over in our minds as if somehow by doing this we can change the past. Living this way can be exhausting.

Some part of us would like to stop running, to come home to the present moment and rest there, but we don’t know how.

The practice of mindfulness helps us to find a place of quiet in our lives, where we can feel safe and steady ourselves. When we learn to rest in the present moment, we are able to be with whatever we are feeling without being overwhelmed and without getting carried away by our fearful thoughts.

This revised version of my earlier book, Depression: A CommonSense Approach, takes you on a journey that involves looking courageously at what happens when you feel depressed and are listening to what it may be trying to tell you about your life. This forms Part One of this book. Part Two gives you some guidance as to how you can get back on your feet and regain some control over your life, so that you don’t continue to feel lost. Putting some structure on your everyday life is necessary so that you can relate to your deeper hurts and wounds. Part Three introduces you to the practice of mindfulness and shows you how you can live with yourself and begin to heal those places in your mind and heart where you remain vulnerable to depression. You will be introduced to specific ways that will help you to rest in the present, pay attention to what is happening in your body and find stability. When you have taken time to practise these skills, you will be able to be open to painful emotions and thoughts without becoming overwhelmed. These exercises can prevent you from slipping back into an experience of depression, which can be a very demoralising and heart-breaking experience for anyone who feels they have already put depression behind them.

It is possible for any human being to ‘lose their way’, but it is equally possible for any human being to ‘find their way’. When we feel lost, it is not because of what’s happening or what is missing in our life; we only feel lost when we cannot see what is happening and when we become too frightened to be with ourselves. The moment you can name what is there and be with your experience, you will not feel so lost.

Being mindful, being present to ourselves, connects us with our inner strength. We discover that no matter how broken we may feel, we are also fully human and whole, and we have an amazing capacity to hold and transform whatever is happening in our awareness, with compassion.

Recovery is a path that each of us follows as we engage more openly and more courageously with the life we have been given. Your path to recovery is not something that anyone can point out to you. It is something you discover, one step at a time, and it always begins with the place you are in right now. Mindfulness can help us to see beyond the noise level of our thoughts to the supports that are available to us, and clear a space in our mind where new insights can emerge.

The way ahead is particular to each person as they learn what works for them and what enables them to be themselves. Some parts of this book may be especially meaningful to one reader and not so relevant to another. I have divided it into three distinct parts that stand alone and which can be read in any order, depending on the particular difficulty a person may be facing.

Depression is not a power in our lives. We ourselves are the power in our lives. When we forget that and when we believe we are worthless, we lose sight of where we are going. By rediscovering the power in ourselves, we rediscover the will to live life in a more meaningful way, and we learn to love ourselves again in a deeper way.

I hope that you will find in these pages an understanding of depression that not only helps you to overcome the pain of depression, but that also helps you to learn how to live your life. May it help you to become more aware of places in your heart that need to heal, give you the confidence to face whatever frightens you, and enable you to discover the freedom to be yourself more fully.

Tony Bates

May 2011

While the author has made every effort to ensure that the information contained in this book is accurate, it should not be regarded as an alternative to professional medical advice. Readers should consult their general practitioners or physicians if they are concerned about aspects of their own health, and before embarking on any course of treatment. Neither the author nor the publisher can accept responsibility for any health problem resulting from using, or discontinuing, any of the drugs described here, or the self-help methods described.

CONTENTS

line1

Cover

Title Page

Audio Tracks: A Mindful Approach to Recovery

Preface

Disclaimer

Introduction

Part One: Understanding Depression

1. The experience of depression

2. What causes depression?

Part Two: Recovery from Depression

3. Taking action to relieve your mood

4. Catching your thoughts

5. Changing your self-image

6. Putting it all together: Tom’s story

7. Supporting a person who is depressed

Part Three: Living With Yourself

8. How ‘mindfulness’ can support recovery

9. Learning to be mindful

10. Relating mindfully to your body

11. Relating mindfully to your emotions

12. Relating mindfully to your thoughts

13. Living mindfully

Postscript: Beyond Depression

References and Resources

Permission Acknowledgments

Copyright

Dedication

Praise for Coming Through Depression

Acknowledgments

About the Author

About Gill & Macmillan

Introduction

line1

Susan was tall, blonde and in her late twenties. Her outward appearance suggested a self-contained, confident woman, but her eyes told a different story. The day she first arrived, she looked as if she’d rather have been anywhere else than talking to me. Her movements were awkward and stiff. She avoided making eye contact and I hesitated to ask her why she’d come, sensing it might be an invasion of a privacy that she was anxiously guarding. We danced around the central issue for a while as I pieced together a profile of her family background, her schooling and occupation, and her current circumstances. She relaxed a little but when I asked what had brought her to see me, her fragile holding together gave way to a flood of tears.

Words failed Susan as she tried vainly to account for her terrible sadness. She felt she had no right to complain but she described how in recent weeks she had found herself collapsing into tears for no apparent reason, overcome by the feeling that she was stupid, worthless and completely out of control. She apologised repeatedly for her demeanour.

She struck me as someone who didn’t normally, if ever, let down her guard about her inner struggles. But on this occasion the intensity of her inner pain refused to be silenced and she had sought counselling to help her make some sense of it all.

In writing this book, I think about Susan on that first visit, and many others who have come and confronted their own very personal experience of depression. All have been confused and frightened by what was happening to them. Their own desperation, the experience of ‘losing a grip’ on work and life, or the helpless exasperation of close loved ones, prompted them to reach out and look for help.

I imagine you are reading this book having struggled also with depression, either directly or indirectly, through living with someone who is visited and revisited by this problem. My hope is that you will find in Susan’s story, and in the accounts of others’ struggles with depression, some echo of your own experience, and realise that you are not ‘mad’ or ‘stupid’ or ‘horribly selfish’.

There are reasons why someone becomes depressed; being able to understand and make sense of the experience can help to restore one’s dignity and morale. There are also ways to recover from depression and stay well that this book will describe in some detail. And there are ways in which the experience of depression can strengthen your sense of who you are and help you become more aware and appreciative of your life.

Depression is challenging for families and loved ones. Children may sense and feel troubled by a parent’s dark moods; partners even more so. The effort to alleviate the pain of depression in a loved one inevitably fails, and the most well-intended interventions of friends and spouses can leave all concerned feeling helpless and alienated. While this book is primarily intended as a guide to recovery for the sufferer, it is also written with the relatives and friends of the sufferer in mind, in the hope that it may make sense of what can be a difficult problem to grasp from the ‘outside’. An understanding of the problem, by all who are affected, can act as a bridge between people who feel isolated by depression and those who care about them.

The aim of this book is to support and strengthen your recovery from depression. Recovery is not just about feeling better. It means getting to know yourself in a much deeper way than you do now and learning how best to take care of yourself. Your faith in yourself may be shaky right now, but my hope is that in this book you will find a way to connect with your own inner strength.

You might well ask whether I am being realistic in thinking that a simple book like this could change your life in such a profound way. Let me say this first so neither of us has any illusions: nobody can magically take away another’s depression. I can only join with someone who is in this particular pain and help them to discover in themselves a capacity to heal and to confront their pain rather than try to block it out or become overwhelmed by it.

If you are struggling with depression right now, you need a solid ally to help you find your way back home. And, as allies go, it turns out I’m not the worst. I’ve worked with many people for over 25 years to help them recover from depression and I have battled through many a dark night of the soul myself. Like a tracker who knows the territory, I can help to guide you and direct you to useful strategies that may help your recovery.

At the same time, I recognise that a book like this one is no substitute to you finding a trustworthy professional to work with during your recovery. Self-help literature is often most useful when it is used as part of a recovery plan that may well include medication and/or therapy. We will talk more about this later, but do consider engaging someone competent to help you find your way out of depression. Your GP can advise you on how best to start looking for the right person. One of the benefits of reading this book is that it may help to clarify what kind of help you need.

Sarah, whose journals we will be dipping in and out of throughout this book, was a young woman with whom I worked. When we first met, she was 21 years old and in a very dark place. With her permission, I have included excerpts from the journal she kept over the course of five months, when, as an in-patient, she struggled to find a way out of depression. I learned a great deal from Sarah, and from many others whose accounts of recovery I have also included in these pages.

Sarah’s recovery journal

Excerpt 1

Depression is like an assignment in life that nobody ever sets for you to do. No one tells you beforehand how difficult it’s going to be, how time-consuming it is, how painful it can be. You’re not prepared for it and when it happens, you want to give it all away and collapse into nothing. Because there are no real signs, no real markers, no sheets handed out beforehand, telling you what it’s going to be like. And before you know it, you’re being judged, not on your progress but on your failures, on your weaknesses. The judge isn’t a fair one with guidelines and suggestions. The judge is yourself, the ‘worst’ around, who shatters your confidence and who plays on your vulnerabilities until you get to the point where you want to break. You want to give up on this assignment that seems so wasteful and pointless.

But it’s really the most important assignment you’ll be given. It’s an essay which is long and tiresome but where you must come out with full marks. Those full marks won’t be given for content or structure or quality. They’ll be given each time you believe in yourself and care for yourself a little more. And you’re the one who calls out the grade, because you’re the one giving yourself those stars. The assignment is you, and you are the judge, the expert, the one who knows you and cares about you and loves you enough to say, ‘I’m worth it, I’m worth 100 per cent.’

PART ONE

line1

Understanding Depression

CHAPTER 1

The experience of depression

line1

Depression! Depression is not a word that for a long time I would have applied to myself. In retrospect, however, I would probably now accept that I have been depressed over a long number of years and in need of some help.

Mary, aged 39

Depression is a very common term that many people can relate to in some way. We have all had our share of losses and felt sad; we have all made mistakes and experienced disappointments and setbacks. These experiences may have left us feeling upset and confused. They may have been quite shattering and taken some time to get over. So we know what it’s like to feel sadness and distress and we may wonder what makes our experience any different from what is referred to as ‘depression’ in a clinical or medical sense.

When someone feels sad, or when they experience a passing, depressed mood, it is generally a normal and healthy response to some misfortune they have experienced. Most of the time, their mood is a reaction to the loss of a person, a social role, a close companion or a place to which they felt attached. A person who feels sad knows they have lost something and they yearn for its return. Generally, they will share their grief with someone and be open to receiving whatever support they get as they come to terms with their loss. For a period of time, they will grieve until they can gradually accept their loss. Their emotional life and their capacity to work and relate to others may be temporarily disrupted. This is a natural part of coming to terms with the new situation they find themselves in and learning to re-engage with life without whomever or whatever they have lost.

Depression is something different. Whereas sadness and grief are focused entirely around an experience of loss, depression refers to an experience where a person becomes convinced that there is something seriously wrong with them. If sadness is a natural response to loss, depression is a very painful experience of believing oneself to be a ‘loser’. In depression, a person’s distress may have been triggered by some loss in their life, but their attention very quickly shifts away from whatever they have lost to a preoccupation with a personal sense of failure, inadequacy and helplessness. Lacking any belief that they are worthwhile, they may turn away from others and become withdrawn and unresponsive to offers of help.

When someone becomes depressed, it is not simply that they feel down. Their capacity to think clearly and make decisions is diminished, their physical health suffers, and the energy they normally have to deal with life drains away. A person who becomes depressed also experiences a complete lack of satisfaction from the activities, relationships and pastimes that had always given their lives a sense of meaning and joy.

Because depression can be so disabling and so intensely painful, it is regarded as being as much of an illness as any other form of physical suffering. It can last for a long time and a person may feel utterly hopeless about whether or not they will ever recover. When depression persists for a long time, a person may begin to feel that they are an intolerable burden to others and convince themselves that everyone might be better off if they were no longer around.

This book is about the experience of feeling down that seems to take hold of us, that doesn’t shift easily and that causes us significant difficulty in getting through our everyday lives.

This experience is commonly referred to as clinical depression and it is as much a physical experience as it is an emotional experience. Clinical depression causes us such difficulty that it becomes extremely hard for us to live our lives in a way that we want for ourselves. People who become clinically depressed may feel confused, terrified and fearful and no longer in charge of their own lives.

In the early stage of her depression, Sarah described her experience in her journal. Her account conveys the sense of confusion and isolation so characteristic of depression.

Sarah’s recovery journal

Excerpt 2

These days, I don’t know what to do with my time. Almost everything seems so futile, nothing seems to have any importance any more. I don’t feel really depressed all the time, just bogged down with living. I spend a lot of time in a daze, as though I’m hiding things from myself; my memory is blocked, my feelings are blocked and I feel like a walking stone statue. Some of the time, I think I feel OK, but then my mood changes and I become frightened again. I move back on occasions during the day to those so familiar periods of despair when inside my head I can hear myself screaming, ‘Help me, what am I supposed to do?’

Signs of depression

Depression is characterised by a particular set of changes in how a person thinks, feels and behaves. As well as being an experience of intense psychological suffering, a person’s sense of physical wellbeing is greatly affected, and sleep, appetite and energy levels are all disturbed. The primary signs or ‘symptoms’ of depression are discussed below and illustrated in the diagram below. The symptoms in this diagram are categorised and grouped according to their impact on our thinking and our feeling, and on our behaviours and our physical health.

SYMPTOMS OF DEPRESSION

1

Ways of thinking that are characteristic of depression

As Tim describes below, a person who is depressed thinks about their world in a very negative way.

You’re in a café, you’re talking to someone and you’re not even able to listen to what they’re saying: the other customers’ cups grate too loudly on their saucers, you’re worried you’ve offended the waitress because you forgot to say ‘please’, and of course you don’t want your mate to realise you’re not paying attention. Everything ends up stewed down to its component fibres because you’re looking at it all so hard. You’re seeing too much and too deeply, and holding all those details together in your mind is taking up all of your effort.

John, aged 21

The past, the present and the future are all viewed though a dark lens that distorts everything. Important achievements in the past don’t count. She or he focuses exclusively on every sign of failure or weakness that they can possibly point to in their life. They see the future as a relentless continuation of their current misery where nothing good will ever happen for them. These preoccupations make it hard to concentrate on anything or to believe there is any good in themselves. Making a decision can be an enormous strain because they don’t trust themselves to do the right thing.

Sarah, in her darkest moments of depression, described how her sense of hopelessness was overwhelming.

Sarah’s recovery journal

Excerpt 3

I can’t do anything any more. Anytime I attempt to work, I clog up inside and leave it. I don’t do anything because I don’t think that I can. There’s no point, it’s all so hopeless. Even if I do try, I get nowhere. I have absolutely no belief in myself any more. There’s no hope in my heart, there’s no happiness in my thoughts. I feel as if I’m tied up and can’t break loose. I’m too afraid to do anything because I think I’ll fail and it’ll only make me feel worse, and so I do nothing. But that makes me feel so bad because all I do is sit around and do nothing. I’m so lazy. I don’t understand anything. What’s the point? It’s all so useless, and worthless and utterly hopeless and I hate it. I’m so afraid.

Other people very often view people who are depressed as being terribly ‘selfish’. While it is true that their thoughts seem to centre exclusively on themselves, and that their behaviour might seem very self-centred, it is not accurate to say they are ‘selfish’. Such pain is generated within the mind when a person is depressed that the person is often unable to consider the needs of others or to contribute to activities where they would normally play an active role.

The physical symptoms of depression

Depression is for many people a very physical experience and the symptoms they describe are often to do with changes in their body. They may describe the sensation of hurting deeply inside or they may have physical symptoms which worry them, but which have no apparent physical cause. Sleep disturbance is probably the most common physical symptom of depression. Sufferers usually report a broken sleep pattern that results in waking without the sense of being rested or refreshed. Their normal appetite may also be affected, resulting in either excessive eating and weight gain, or a complete lack of interest in food, which leads to weight loss. They may also find themselves unable to make love and indeed have very little interest in doing so, and this can be a major worry for them.

Behavioural characteristics of depression

It is not always easy to recognise that someone may be depressed. No matter how intensely distressed they may feel inside, many people hide it very well on the outside. And even when someone behaves out of character, we may not realise that they are depressed, and mistake their behaviour for something else.

This is often the case with children and adolescents who may express their inner turmoil in behaviour that appears destructive and anti-social. For example, an adolescent may begin to act in an uncharacteristic way, participating in shoplifting, fire-setting or disruptive behaviour at school, and never get the support for what is really troubling them. An adult’s sudden lack of interest in sexual intimacy may be interpreted as rejection, or they may start to drink heavily and procrastinate and get into trouble for not delivering on their work responsibilities. All of these behaviours result in life being more difficult for anyone experiencing depression and can reinforce their belief that they are fundamentally bad.

A significant slowing down in activity is a very common feature of depression, although some sufferers can become restless, even hyperactive, as they try to block out the turmoil they experience inside. Excessive ‘busy-ness’ can be a protective mechanism to distract from this turmoil, but it leaves a person feeling constantly on edge and irritable. Sometimes being busy can seem preferable to the prospect of slowing down and acknowledging that something is not right. Susan, who was mentioned in the introduction, put this very succinctly when she said, ‘You make yourself very vulnerable when you stop to think!’

Most commonly, the behaviour that is characteristic of depression is marked by lack of energy and social withdrawal. One man in his mid-thirties, described how his ‘get-up-and-go was all gone’. There is little energy to devote to external demands and concerns when you are depressed. A tendency to take to the bed is all too common. Sometimes it can seem easier just to retreat from the world to avoid having to deal with the criticism, demands, even concerns, of loved ones and friends.

Feelings that are characteristic of depression

If you have never been depressed, it is hard to appreciate just how intensely painful depression can feel. People who are depressed often find it very hard to put their feelings into words. They also fear that if they were to say how badly they were feeling, other people may be shocked and write them off as insane. Sarah described the feeling of being depressed in the following way:

I’m so distressed because I don’t know what’s going on in my head. It’s confusing and I feel frightened and unsure about everything I do. I used to be happy and cheerful and confident. I used to enjoy my life. Where has everything gone? I don’t understand why I feel like this, why I feel so worn out, sad and lonely. I need warmth. I need to be warmed up inside. Everything’s gone cold and strange. I’d love for someone to give me a big hug, but if I asked, I feel that they wouldn’t understand why and that they would think I was crazy.

Emotions can be so intense when you’re depressed that you can become frightened of your inner world. You do whatever you can to suppress your feelings and block them out. Your body may become tense with the worry about what you are feeling. Or you may resort to abusing alcohol or other substances to shut down your feelings and make yourself as numb as possible.

Severe and mild depression

‘’